Why did the novelists only staged drama disappear for so long?
Save this article to read it later.
Find this story in your accountsSaved for Latersection.
The soiree was at the Steuben Club in Albany, a half-hour before the premiere.
The gray-haired star of the evening had not been expected to make an appearance.
But there she was, wearing a bow-tie scarf and spiked heels, accompanied by her two sons.
Youre supposed to be nervous, someone shouted.
I am, Toni Morrison replied.
For Morrison, this was a new worldsort of.
But she wasnt afraid to dip in and out of other mediums.
The production,New Orleans: The Storyville Musical,had not, alas, been a success.
Public Theater founder Joseph Papp staged readings in New York City, but thats as far as it went.
The show was never produced, and Morrison didnt give it pride of place among her works.
Now, at the outset of 1986, the novelist was about to debut her first full-length play.
Milam while visiting family in Mississippi.
She was excited about the script and did revisions throughout the months of rehearsals.
I thought it was an extraordinary theatrical idea, she told a journalist that night.
A way to handle history.
She planned to takeDreaming Emmettto Paris after the initial run.
It was not to be.
Copies of the play would disappear.
Cast member Joseph C. Phillips saved a copy.
Althougha fireconsumed Morrisons home in Nyack on Christmas Day 1993, singed copies ofDreaming Emmettsurvived.
It may even provide a new understanding of howBeloved, her most celebrated novel, came together.
Rather than simply relish his happiness, however, the novelists thoughts turned dark.
She wondered, as she later put it: What do you lose when a 14-year-old is killed?
The killing of Americas Black youth was, for Morrison, top of mind.
More recently, there was the death of Michael Stewart in Morrisons own city.
Morrison knew the deaths of Stewart and the children in Atlanta were not the result of their own actions.
(Lovedied of an AIDS-related illness in 1991.)
While there were recent inspirations for it, she drew primarily from Tills 1955 murder.
Till was murdered when Morrison was in graduate school at Cornell University.
Her purpose, Morrison told a reporter, was to act as a kind of chorus.
This was an audacious idea and not an intuitive one for a theatrical production in 1983.
(As Morrison later wrote, Nothing is deader than a thirty-year-old headline.)
But it would be ideal for a bureaucrat in upstate New York.
As Gibson sat on the floor, enthralled, she decided that a play by Morrison would be ideal.
Gibson had no notion of Morrisons work in progress.
Upon returning to Albany, recalled Bouchard, he and Clough agreed it was a hallucinogenic hellscape.
In the months that followed, the play was transformed.
Neither Clough nor Bouchard know what prompted the changes.
In every way possible, this play should have the quality of a dream, Morrison would write.
In practice, Morrisons revisions had madeDreaming Emmettconvoluted and diminished the power of the original idea.
In the fall of 1985, production onDreaming Emmettbegan.
He understood intuitively how vital it was to stage a play written, directed, and starring Black people.
We as blacks are starved for images of ourselves all over this country, Moses once said.
But one could envision friction.
(Moses died in 1995.)
Morrison and Moses watched two actors try out for the lead roles of Emmett and Tamara.
Okay, you people, Moses said, start whenever you want.
As the young actors performed a scene, the room fell silent.
During a break for lunch, Morrison suggested the actress hadnt been appropriate for the role.
This Tamara is translating the ghetto sass into anger, and its not quite right.
The instinctIm not sure she has it, she said.
Tamara has to have a deflective quality, and whatever this one has, it aint that!
On the first day alone, more than 30 actors auditioned.
(She would later go on to co-star inOrange Is the New Black).
The New YorkTimespraised Toussaints performance in the latter production for its simplicity and size.
Joseph C. Phillips was cast as Emmett.
At 23, he was noticeably older than the real-life Till.
By the end of the fall, the playwas fully cast.
Even in its pared-back state, however, Moses demanded an elaborate set.
The creative process grew and grew, said Jordan.
Mosess frustrations were felt by the actors, with whom he had an antagonistic relationship.
Moses sternly told Phillips that his input wasnt welcome.
He knew how to bully people.
A friendly face might conceal a murderer.
All of the characters are themselves masks.
The creative decisions kept adding to the bottom line.
According to an internal memo, the average Capital Rep production for the 1985-86 season cost $27,686.
The budget forDreaming Emmettnow exceeded $70,000.
The expenses, as well as Mosess imperiousness, spurred a contentious meeting in early December.
Morrison was so upset she began to cry.
Everyone involved acquiesced to Moses and Morrisons increasingly expensive demands.
But the board members, disturbed by the meeting, offered to scrap the production altogether.
The offer was, of course, rebuffed.Dreaming Emmettopened as planned and was a box-office success.
Its difficult, from a present-day vantage, to imagine Toni Morrison unsure of herself.
But she had undeniably hot and cold feelings about the play.
But there were also periods, even after Albany, when she viewedDreaming Emmettas unfinished.
Was she simply aware of her inexperience as a playwright?
Quite possibly this is why shed engaged a dramaturg in the first place.
But to see them standing up, walking around, I dont know how to do it.
Maybe so, butDreaming Emmett, flawed as it is, holds an undeniable power.
Im thinking of Mas reaction when Emmett flippantly asks if she cares about him.
she replies to the ghost, inspecting her palms.
What do you see here?
Theres nothing in them is there?
I had my hands full with you, with work with trouble.
Or when Emmett asks Major, So, am I the last Emmett Till?
Not by a long shot, the Roy Bryant stand-in replies.
You wasnt the first and you aint the last.
We will stop you in alleys; well stop you in the parks.
We will stop you on the buses, the subwaysanywhere you misbehave.
Ultimately,Dreaming of Emmettmay be important not as a stand-alone work but for how it helped its author.
Prior toDreaming Emmett, Morrison had been having difficulties with her novel, set during the Reconstruction era.
She hadnt quite figured out the title character, the spirit of a murdered baby girl.
Morrison knew there wasnt much of a precedent for a novelist writing a successful play.
Even Henry James hadnt pulled it off, shed say.
Regional critics had agreed to attend.
But so, too, had the critic fromTime.
The critic understandably refused.
Nevertheless, at the reception beforeDreaming Emmetts premiere, the novelist radiated optimism.
She and her pal William Kennedy happily chatted.
She introduced her kids to the guests.This is Ford.
If Morrison was nervous, she didnt show it as she drank in the accolades.
Correction: Morrison wrote about the use of masks inTar Babyin a 2004 foreword to her novel.
Thank you for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
